RELATIONAL CRITICAL REALISM · GIOVANNI PROSPERI

Beyond Nothingness

Why is there something rather than nothing? A philosophical investigation of necessary Being, relational determination, and the conditions of consciousness.

A different starting point

Most explanations of existence begin with a cause, an initial state, or a foundational substance. In Beyond Nothingness, I begin with a different question: is absolute nothingness a coherent metaphysical alternative at all?

I then use a method I call subtractive derivation. Rather than adding explanatory entities, I ask which conditions cannot be removed without losing the possibility of determinate Being.

The argument in brief

I argue that the impossibility of absolute nothingness entails the necessity of some Being; that determinate Being requires difference; and that difference involves relational constraints and structural manifestability.

I also defend Consciousness as the manifest pole. This further thesis depends on a principle of operational determinacy that I argue for, but do not derive from subtraction alone. I make this distinction explicit in edition 3.7.

A theory with declared limits

I do not claim to derive the laws of physics or explain causally how biological consciousness emerges. I seek minimal ontological constraints, carefully distinguishing my stronger arguments from exploratory proposals such as the levels of integrated consciousness.

The central question

What if the question “why is there something rather than nothing?” rests on a false alternative?

SOURCE IN THE BOOK · EDITION 3.7

Introduction; Chapters 1–3; methodological note; Chapter 8.

PhilArchive ↗· PhilPapers ↗· Zenodo (EN) — DOI 3.7 ↗· Zenodo (IT) — DOI 3.7 ↗

IN THE ORIGINAL WORDS OF THE AUTHOR

Follow the complete argument

In my book I develop the full arguments, objections and stated limits. This site offers an accessible introduction to my work.

Explore the original work →